"Nathan Mittleman, as Billy Lawlor has boyish looks, a nice tenor voice and superb dancing skill."

- Tom Williams, Chicago Critic

​

"Mr. Mittleman is the unlikeliest looking Dick Powell-type leading man, but his bravado and super sweet tenor make him fascinating to watch."

- Tony Frankel, Stage and Cinema

"Minor characters who hold their own include...Nathan Mittleman as Teen Angel..."

- Julie McHale, TimeOut

"Nathan Mittleman breathes life into the vain, self-serving announcer, Bert Healy."

- Doris Lynch, The Herald-Times